ed_rex: (Default)

Not a problem this time (I think)

posted by [personal profile] ed_rex at 12:52pm on 18/05/2011
As I've posted elsewhere, Moffat's penchant for turning the Doctor into a killer who loves killing is a major problem for me.

But this time, I thought it worked. I didn't get the sense that the Doctor enjoyed killing House (or rather, enjoyed watching the TARDIS kill house), but rather that he was incredibly relieved that the TARDIS was able to survive.

It's a subtle difference in tone (as others have pointed out in reply to your post, the Doctor has always been willing to kill, what's weird with 11 is that he so often enjoys it), but I think Gaiman's script stays true to the spirit of Who, where Moffat keeps betraying it.

Similarly, I thought Rory's "death" scene for once, wasn't a cheat. Gaiman made sure we knew that Amy (and Rory) were being mentally tortured and so we weren't supposed to believe that Rory was dead, but only that Amy thought he was.

For the first time since "Vincent and the Doctor", I'm happy with an episode of Doctor Who!
[parent entry] [link] [reply]
jhumor: (Default)

(no subject)

posted by [personal profile] jhumor at 01:05pm on 18/05/2011
Seeing as these are the only things I could see wrong with it, I think this was a very good episode. Like you, the first I've really enjoyed since Vincent and the Doctor.

My point, is that there are still those elements that seem to be obviously Moff's influence. And while the rest of you aren't bothered by it, I am within my right to continue to be.
[link] [parent] [reply]

March

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
            1
 
2
 
 3
 
 4
 
 5
 
 6
 
 7
 
 8
 
9
 
 10
 
 11
 
 12
 
 13
 
 14
 
 15
 
16
1
 17
 
 18
 
 19
 
 20
 
 21
 
 22
 
23
 
 24
 
 25
 
 26
 
 27
 
 28
 
 29
 
30
 
 31