Question

[apollodorus]

 The first two episodes of the new season were exciting, don't get me wrong.  But ....

 

.....   there was a total disconnect between the end of the first episode and the beginning of the second episode.   I was scratching my head as to what was going on.  If they were all working for Nixon, why did they have to pretend to be on the run from the FBI, with the various associated Faked Death and Faked Imprisonment theatrics?   I felt there was like 15 minutes of exposition between the episodes that got cut in the final edit.

 

Comments

[matgb]

Did you miss the bit where Canton finally sealed the Doctor in and they discussed the reason for the deceit?

The Silence are everywhere controlling everyone that matters through subliminal instructions. Ergo they needed to be tricked into thinking Canton was on side and dealing with their biggest threat.

[apollodorus]

It still felt like there was a scene or two missing. It was bit of sloppy transition.

Oh, well. I otherwise enjoyed the ep.

[spikewriter]

I remember somewhere Moffat saying that he felt the second half of a two-parter should never open exactly where Part One left off. His reasoning is that since it'd been a week since the viewer had last seen our heroes, there should at least be a change of scene -- also that he didn't care for the opening of "The Doctor Dances" for just that reason.

::shrug:: It's clearly one of his personal writing rules.

[jhumor]

Which was FINE in Silence in the Library... it actually WORKED there, because we were suddenly following 'adventures of Donna'. Here? there was so much missing that it was more WTF.

And it was so much WTF I almost stopped watching, thinking there was a glitch in the BBC iPlayer.

I said elsewhere: Moff needs an editor or someone to stop him. Really every idea he has doesn't need to be crammed into one (or two) episode(s). And he needs an editor to tighten up aspects that can be tightened and expand things that need more explanation.

And don't think I'm an RTD lover. I'm not. He had his issues too. I'm just someone who's studied a bit of creative writing and I expect more from 'professionals'.

[zacksfan]

Hi, I am a lurker but I felt that These 2 eps have made me question my favourite series in a way that I never want to. I agree that something was missing and it was so glaring that I hated the Dy of the Moon up until they started getting out of the body bags because it was going in the direction of (look the doctor is not as clever as you thought, the FBI has bested them. The FBI is mightier than the Daleks)

It was more frustrating than entertaining and that to me is NOT what Dr Who is about.